Visualize yourself walking through a lively artisan market where each stall oozes color, scent, and narrative — this is exactly how “Mentors,” the latest 12-track album from Fish in a Birdcage, caresses the senses. The initial chord hits and for a moment you can taste the edge of creative zeal in the air. Dusty Townsend, the Canadian singer-songwriter behind the project, has an otherworldly knack for blending folk-pop intricacies with alternative pop textures. Certainly, the outcome is a kaleidoscopic adventure that plumbs tender introspection while flirting with raucous, orchestral eruptions.

Townsend’s folk origins are evident in the gentle lilt of acoustic guitars and the lush cello lines that thread through arrangements like strands of gold. But the album stretches far beyond any narrow folk designation. There are touches of baroque pop grandeur and some cinematic soundscapes (that shimmer with orchestral heft). The unifying theme of mentorship — learning from and honoring the people who help us along — lends a contemplative dimension, almost as if the musician has blended a lifetime’s worth of suffering and lessons into one story that fits into one mental book. The effect is stirring, at times overpowering, and ultimately, redemptive.

A quick hop through the dozen tracks shows the album’s strengths and difficulties. The opener, “Microphone,” establishes tone with an ever-more-dramatic build that teases the question: If you had the world’s ear, what would you say? Its swelling intensity and galvanizing percussion create something of a theatrical atmosphere, yet the song sidesteps melodrama by mixing personal details with broad philosophical questions. At times this dramatic air can get a little heavy-handed, but the earnestness of Townsend’s performance prevents it from crossing into kitsch territory.

“Long Way From Home” follows, revealing a muted tapestry of brooding drums and plaintive vocals. The track also provides a hint of yearning for a more meaningful social structure. One hears echoes of some nomadic philosophy—rootless, searching—but the echo never sounds in empty space. Instead, it’s staved off with glimmers of hope that suggest reimagining what ‘home’ can be. And indeed, Townsend’s lyricism here conveys a vivid sense of longing without being drenched in despair.

At the conceptual core of the album is its titular “Mentors.” Over-directed with reverence for those who make us, the piece includes tensely quiet guitar riffs and cello swells that lay a foundation for its message. It has an airy melodic elegance akin to the grandeur of Patrick Wolf or Owen Pallett, yet Townsend’s trademark sincerity and vocal warmth maintains a sense of personal over ostentatious. One possible criticism might be that its chorus — which displays a few repetitions in its time — might come off as somewhat roundabout, but that kind of repetition also solidifies the anthemic coloring of the track.

The fourth song, “Elders,” slows the pace with a meditational groove centered around intergenerational wisdom. There’s a sense of muted urgency, as if Townsend were struggling to address contemporary concerns, while still holding out for ancient understanding. Then comes “Lore”, a soulful chamber-pop meditation on the importance of oral tradition. The swirling strings and woodwinds serve as examples of the album’s ornate production, wrapping the listener in a comforting storybook vibe.

“Brave” adds a bolder entry to the fray, showcasing a more vulnerable facet. Pulsing percussion and contemplative lyrics about facing one’s weaknesses toe a fine line between confession and battle cry. And while its melody can be a little unvarying, “Brave” has the merit of Townsend’s plaintive delivery, which ensures the song is rooted in authenticity.

“C’est La Vie” offers a more philosophical turn, examining how we respond — or don’t — to the snares of life. The song’s acoustic underpinnings keep it grounded, but the slightly cryptic nature of the lyrics offers multiple listens to unravel the poetic layers fully. Then, “Fever Pitch” provides a buoyant surge of energy, celebrating the miracles of being alive. Bright strings and anthemic refrains are a reminder that life is brief, though energetic, and they won’t let the flickering torch of hope be extinguished.

“Chosen” breathes on a raw confessional note, recognizing one’s own shortcomings in the same breath as a steady insistence on betterment. A heady progression gives this tune a weird taste that matches Townsend’s experimental folk-pop identity. The track “Badger” comes next, a relentless, driving force that confronts perseverance head-on. It’s a gritty story, told in lightly percussive flourishes and metaphorical lyrics, about a spirit trying to hang onto your back rather than let you wallow in defeat. It might be a bit familiar in structure for some, but it’s tough to argue with its motivational spark.

Next is “Rooftop Jam,” a buoyant anthem of creative synchronicity. One can almost hear an apartment roof at night, guitar in hand, building ephemeral relations. Finally, “Poet” ends the album in a soft wash of introspection, inviting the listener to share their own truths, when they feel ready. And the softness of its parting notes lingers, as though Townsend and company are cheering us on from the sidelines, urging us to find our own spotlight.

All in all, “Mentors” is a luscious tapestry, knitting together the story of Townsend’s musical evolution. This fifth album reflects a more mature grasp of arrangement, lyricism and thematic ambition. The interplay of strings, folk-pop instrumentation and poetic flourishes can verge on the grandiose, but there is real heart in every note. Indeed, some songs feel perhaps a little over-instrumented, leaving purists craving the occasional bare strips of sound to showcase the raw nature of Townsend’s voice. But those momentary qualms do little to undermine the overarching tapestry of wisdom, wonder and warmth.

Whether you label it a gastronomy feast of sounds or a painterly canvas, “Mentors” demonstrates what is possible when an investment of time and energy prepares the ground for a creation that is at once intensely personal and universal. Anyone who’s had a yearning for earnest storytelling, evocative layers of instruments, and a galvanizing call to honor life’s lessons will find solace and inspiration in these 12 songs. The invitation, I think, is plain: We are all fledgling on this twisting journey, and Townsend’s tender steering just might help us find the sages we didn’t know we needed.

Enjoyed the read? Consider showing your support by leaving a tip for the writer

TRENDING NOW

CONNECT WITH US

FEATURED